Comparing UK State Schools with Private Schools: What Should New Teachers Know?

New teachers face different working conditions in UK state and private schools. State schools generally follow established pay scales and have larger classes, while private schools often offer smaller classes but longer working days. Your choice also affects your induction, pension, and workload.

These differences aren’t always clear in job adverts, especially when schools describe similar roles with different expectations. That’s why we’ve put together this guide to help you understand your options before accepting a contract.

We’ll compare UK state schools vs private schools on pay, workload, curriculum, and training. Keep your job adverts open beside you as you read.

Pay and Pensions: How UK State and Private Schools Reward New Teachers

Young teacher seated at a school office desk in morning sunlight

Because each private school writes its own pay policy, two offers in the same town can differ on salary, pay rises, and extra duties. So before you compare offers, ask each school for its written policy, not just the advertised figure. Use the table below to line up five points to check in any offer letter.

PointUK State SchoolsUK Private Schools
Starting salaryFixed by the national main pay range, with higher bands in LondonSet by each school, sometimes matched to the state scale and sometimes above or below it
Pay progressionYearly steps up the main pay range, linked to appraisalDecided by the school’s own pay policy, which may have no fixed steps
Pension schemeTeachers’ Pension Scheme; a defined benefit plan with a large employer contributionTeachers’ Pension Scheme in some schools, a smaller defined contribution plan in others
Contract typeNational terms on hours, sick pay and notice periodsIndividual contracts that can add Saturday and boarding duties
Extra benefitsFew perks beyond salary and pensionPossible housing, free meals and fee discounts for staff children

The pension generally decides more offers than the salary, because a defined benefit pension pays a guaranteed retirement income based on your earnings. So when a private school pays more but has left the Teachers’ Pension Scheme, ask what its new plan pays in before you compare totals (the pension gap can easily outweigh a higher starting salary).

Why Does Teacher Workload Look So Different in the UK Education System?

Secondary school teacher sitting alone at a desk

Teacher workload differs a lot because UK state schools pack hours into marking and data. Meanwhile, private schools spread them across longer days, Saturdays and co-curricular duties. In fact, a 2024 survey by Private Education Policy Forum (PEPF) tracks teacher workload UK-wide. It found that 60% of staff in UK state schools reported unmanageable workloads, against 37% in top private schools.

However, these figures reflect staff perceptions of workload rather than the total hours they work. Three factors explain where those hours go in each setting.

Class Sizes and Marking Loads in Each Setting

Class size affects marking loads because every extra pupil adds another book to check. Classrooms in UK state schools are often full to capacity, while private schools commonly keep groups of 15 or fewer.

On top of marking, UK state schools ask for regular data entry on pupil progress. You’ll feel this most in the weeks before reports go home (the extra work can stretch well into your evenings).

Before accepting a role, ask the school how often it collects assessment data and how much marking teachers must complete each week. Whichever setting you pick, some time management strategies can help you batch marking into set slots.

What Boarding Duties and Saturday Lessons Add in Private Schools

Boarding duties and Saturday lessons add whole working sessions that never appear on a UK state schools timetable. A boarding duty can mean supervising evening prep, lights out and an overnight on-call shift.

Along with that, Saturday mornings often bring lessons and then afternoon sports fixtures. Thankfully, some private schools pay extra for these. Others simply write them into the contract without any extra remuneration. In our experience reading teaching job adverts, this detail rarely makes the headline description.

The good news is, most UK state schools keep weekends free in their contracts, although after-school clubs and parents’ evenings still add hours.

So we suggest: before signing, ask how many boarding nights and Saturdays each term includes, and get the answer in writing.

Do Longer Holidays Balance the Pressure of the Academic Year?

Those extra evenings and Saturdays raise another question about time off. Many private schools have shorter terms and longer holidays than UK state schools, which generally follow a 190-day teaching year. Even so, the first week off can disappear into sleep and catch-up marking if the pressure is high.

For a fair way to compare schools, weigh the number of extra holiday days with the hours you’d spend on overtime work. For example, two extra weeks off may seem generous, but weekly Saturday duties could mean working many additional days each year.

Weighing Training, Career Progression and Social Support

Teacher in professional attire standing in a modern school corridor

Beyond the classroom itself, many new teachers never ask whether their first school can legally complete their induction year. Across the career guides we write, we often see this is one question overlooked.

In England, statutory induction lasts two school years, and schools must meet specific requirements to provide it. Below are five support areas to check before you accept an offer:

  1. Statutory Induction and QTS: Every UK state school can register you for statutory induction, which you need after gaining Qualified Teacher Status (QTS). Private schools can offer induction too, but only through an approved appropriate body such as the Independent Schools Teacher Induction Panel. So ask any private school whether it holds that registration before you sign.
  2. Early Career Framework Mentoring: At interview, find out who your mentor will be and when your meetings will take place. A reduced teaching timetable and structured mentoring give early career teachers time to develop their skills. State schools in England provide these during statutory induction, and private schools offering induction must meet the same statutory requirements.
  3. Promotion and Responsibility Pay: Through Teaching and Learning Responsibility payments, UK state schools attach set extra pay to roles like head of year or subject lead. Private schools also create their own titles and allowances, which can move you up faster on a small staff. Check whether the school publishes its pay policy for these posts.
  4. Moving Between Sectors Later: Your QTS remains valid if you move between state and private schools in England. The complication arises when you haven’t completed statutory induction. Not to mention, certain state school posts have restrictions on how long you can teach without completing it. Finishing induction early helps prevent those restrictions from affecting a future move.
  5. Pastoral and SEN Teams: A pupil needs additional learning support, but the person responsible for arranging it may vary by school. State schools must appoint a special educational needs coordinator (SENCO), and both sectors have safeguarding and SEN duties. In this case, smaller schools may divide pastoral responsibilities differently, so find out who handles pupil support and safeguarding concerns.

Confirm the school’s statutory induction arrangements before considering its other career benefits. Once you know you can complete induction there, move on to mentoring, promotion opportunities, and support available for daily teaching responsibilities.

Where Your First Teaching Job Fits Best

Your first teaching job should offer a balance of pay, workload, and career support that suits your needs. Before accepting an offer, consider how each school’s working conditions will affect your induction and daily routine.

Pick UK state schools if you want a guaranteed induction, the Teachers’ Pension Scheme, and a national pay scale from day one. By contrast, private schools may appeal if you prefer smaller classes and longer holidays, although some require boarding duties and Saturday lessons. Either way, check the individual contract before deciding.

On the Culture publishes career advice for teachers at every stage. Send us your questions and help us choose a topic for our next guide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *